Suit against town of Salina alleges cat law is unconstitutional

— Two Salina residents and an animal rescue group are suing the town of Salina in order to have its controversial cat law nullified.

The suit was filed in Supreme Court of Onondaga County on March 23. The plaintiffs in the suit are Becky Zinsmeyer and John Mislinsky, both residents of the town, and the Animal Alliance of Greater Syracuse Inc. (AAGS), which has an office in Salina. Zinsmeyer owns two cats, one of which, a longhaired male named Simon, was trapped by the town in December of last year. Mislinsky owns a shorthaired male named Highlight; according to the suit, he was also caring for a feral female and her three-month-old kitten, which Highlight had fathered. The suit alleges the town trapped the all three cats; the mother and kitten were by the SPCA before Mislinsky could get them out.

In both cases, the suit argues that the town made no effort to determine the owners of the trapped cats before delivering the to the SPCA. The complaint asserts that the cats were trapped without due process of law. Both Zinsmeyer and Mislinsky paid $170 to the SPCA to retrieve their cats. Mislinsky is requesting damages in the amount of $170, while Zinsmeyer is requesting damages in the amount of $500. Those damages will cover the amount she paid to the SPCA, as well as vet bills she had to pay for injuries her cat sustained to his chest while in the trap, according to AAGS President Linda Young.

Moreover, the suit argues that the cat law as a whole is unconstitutional; it violates both the state and federal constitutions. According to the complaint:

Section 70-19 fails to provide due process by failing to give direction to the animal control officer as to what constitutes “reasonable diligence” in attempting to notify the owners of a trapped cat. Thus she cannot “establish an impartial standard by which to notify owners.” Since unclaimed cats are euthanized and there is no uniform way to inform owners, the law constitutes “taking” without notification.

Vote on this Story by clicking on the Icon


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment